OPINION: Child circumcision violates 14th amendment rights

A San Diego-based group wants voters to outlaw circumcisions.

Their mission is a righteous one. Circumcision of infant boys violates their basic rights

In 2005, the American Association of Pediatrics restated its circumcision policy and announced it would not recommend its routine use.  But an astounding number of Americans still circumcise their infant boys and believe it is well within their rights to do so. They’re wrong.

According to the Cornell University Law School’s website, children and adults possess equal rights under the “equal rights” clause of the 14th amendment to the Constitution.

Circumcision is a permanent alteration to the anatomy, and it follows a man into adulthood and partially shapes his sexual identity. In infancy, it is a non-consensual, cosmetic procedure that arguably no one but the most religious of individuals would ever agree to have performed on themselves if it wasn’t forced on them.

While the decision to circumcise isn’t one that is always made out of religious tradition, there does appear to be a strong correlation between those who are religious and those who circumcise their infants even if it isn’t necessarily done for religious reasons.

In 2007, the overall number of American men who reported being circumcised was 75 percent. In Australia, of males 16-to-59, it was 59 percent in 2006. In the UK, of males 16-to-44, it was 16 percent in 2003. In China, among males 3-to-23, only 2.7 percent were circumcised in 2008. The website also indicated that a majority of men in middle-eastern countries have been circumcised, according to circinfo.org.

Even accounting for the age discrepancies in these samples, men in the more religious countries had the procedure performed in much greater numbers.

The primary secular argument for circumcision is AIDS prevention. A few studies, conducted in small communities mostly in the third-world, have shown that men who have been circumcised display a lowered incidence of HIV and AIDS. But as wonderful as this may sound, circumcision will only serve as a preventative measure for a sexually active person. Circumcision will not help infants who contract the disease as a result of the mother, and because infants are not sexually active, there is absolutely no reason to have it performed on a male before he can consent.

UNICEF, an organization that supports circumcision in countries like Kenya, reports that Japan and Germany, two countries that perform circumcision at lower rates than in America, report a similar number of AIDS-related deaths.

UNICEF also refers to any form of female circumcision as genital mutilation, even though the purported benefits are the same.

Every individual, however young, should be entitled to a degree of control over their body. A person’s religious rights should end with that person.

Author: Shaun Kahmann

Share This Post On

2 Comments

  1. I kinda want to throw up now…

    Circumcision is a disgusting, demoralizing and barbaric procedure for BOTH MALE AND FEMALES. It should be outlawed to a point where children must be of an age where they can legally consent under reasonable conditions at which they can “think straight”.

    Circumcising, not toddlers, but infants, yet days old, is disgusting mutilation. To have your new born baby cut is outrageously horrific.

    I hope you take this to mind when you have children.

    Post a Reply
  2. I applaud you for speaking out about this… most people remain silent as millions of children and babies are strapped down and mutilated in the name of god… this isn’t 500BC and there is no reason why this should be happening in this day and age… It is not only a violation of the Human Right to Bodily Integrity, but yes you’re correct… it also violates the 14th Amendment of the Constitution…. Things like laws are not only meant to protect adults but also the weakest among us, the most defenseless like babies screaming to be free… those are who our laws can truly shine and protect the innocent from needless torture that benefits no one. Hundreds of children have died from genital cutting… how many more much perish until we open our eyes and this atrocious attack on our human rights and human dignity?

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>